Fry Pie Factory Recalls Pepperoni Rolls Over Milk Allergen and Cold Chain Failure

Fry Pie Factory LLC of Lancaster, Ohio is voluntarily recalling 850 individual units of Pepperoni Rolls due to an undeclared milk allergen and a process deviation in which the product was not held under refrigeration as required. The recall affects consumers in Ohio and West Virginia who may have purchased the affected rolls.

What Products Are Being Recalled?

• Product: Pepperoni Rolls, Net Wt. 5 oz (141g), individually packaged in a clear plastic bag
• UPC: 601959803041
• Sell by dates: 061226 through 062126
• Quantity: 850 individual units
• Recall Number: H-1136-2026

Why Was This Recall Issued?

The recall was initiated for two separate reasons. First, the product contains milk that was not declared on the label, posing a risk to individuals with milk allergies or severe sensitivities. Second, the pepperoni rolls were not held under refrigeration as required during distribution, a process deviation that can allow harmful bacteria to grow and increase the risk of foodborne illness.

Who Is Affected?

This recall affects consumers who purchased Pepperoni Rolls with sell by dates between 061226 and 062126 in Ohio and West Virginia, where the product was distributed. Individuals with a milk allergy or intolerance are at the greatest risk from this recall. The recall has been classified as Class II, meaning the situation may cause temporary or medically reversible health effects, though the probability of serious adverse health consequences is remote.

What Should You Do?

• Check your packaging for the UPC 601959803041 and sell by dates 061226 through 062126
• Do not eat the recalled Pepperoni Rolls, especially if you or a family member has a milk allergy
• Discard the product or return it to the place of purchase
• Consumers with questions may contact Fry Pie Factory LLC at 501 S High St, Lancaster, OH 43130-4432
• If you or a family member has experienced an allergic reaction after consuming this product, contact a healthcare provider

Official Statement

Fry Pie Factory LLC voluntarily initiated this recall after identifying the undeclared milk allergen and the refrigeration process deviation. The firm notified the public through a visit-based notification method. The recall event was classified by the FDA on July 1, 2026, with an initiation date of June 10, 2026. As of this report, the recall status is listed as completed, and no termination date has been recorded.